The article, Firefox Search Engine Cautions, Recommendations, has been updated to support, at least partially, Firefox version 57+. A big thanks goes to ‘nohamelin’, the developer of the XML Search Engines Exporter/Importer ad-on, who has made available a couple of scripts to import and export the search engine plugins in Firefox version 57+.
Back in the day, Firefox was sort of a hackers power browser that fit a niche market. It was probably the most tweakable mainstream web browser on the planet for both geeks and average users alike. Although it is still highly customizable, it has become less so since Mozilla decided to terminate support for so-called “legacy” add-ons and replace them with WebExtensions of the same type as used by Google Chrome. Matter of fact, Firefox has become a Google Chrome clone as far as i’m concerned and some of us — a core Firefox audience that liked running something different and something that wasn’t ‘Googlized’ — didn’t want anything to do with Google, much less their Chrome web browser.
In its [not so] slow, steady decline and separation from its core values, Mozilla has dumbed-down Firefox to the point where it is hardly recognizable and changed its add-on API several times, thus forcing developers to rewrite their code in order to comply with yet another new standard. The developer of the much loved Search WP extension had this to say:
I’d love to support Firefox 57 (with all my extensions) but
1) Webextensions are just *too* limited. You simply can’t do anything useful with them until somebody adds an API just for you. It already starts with the most basic functionality of SearchWP: there does not seem to be a way to modify the search bar.
2) Mozilla ruthlessly breaking all existing extensions on purpose and removing customization possibilities with every new version of Firefox made me loose trust in the foundation and the browser itself – I’m not willing to spend my spare time on a project that has set a course that goes against everything Firefox once stood for.
And the stupidity continues…
For some time Mozilla has been packaging extensions with Firefox in the form of system add-ons, or “features” as Mozilla calls them. Not only is the option to uninstall these add-ons absent from the user interface, but most people aren’t even aware they exist since they’re hidden from the Add-Ons panel (if you want to know more about system add-ons and how to remove them, read the article, Firefox Configuration Guide for Privacy Freaks and Performance Buffs).
In its latest burst of stupidity, Mozilla is now installing yet another add-on without consulting users, but this time, to their undeserved credit, they have made it removable apparently. ‘Looking Glass‘ appears to be some kind of metrics collection add-on disguised as an augmented reality game created by the PUG Experience Group, whoever the hell they are, and it is part of a series of “Shield Studies” conducted by Mozilla. To see what studies Mozilla has foisted upon you that you didn’t agree to, enter
about:studies in the address bar and then
about:preferences#privacy to opt out. Better yet, stop using the Mozilla version of Firefox altogether.
Of course adding this unwanted crap to Firefox isn’t the worst of it. A while back, Mozilla decided that it needed to jump on the “fake news” bandwagon with its newly created Mozilla Information Trust Initiative in order to steer you away from sources of information that the multi-million dollar Mozilla Foundation decides are not suitable for your consumption.
I no longer suggest using Firefox, at least not the version distributed by Mozilla. If you want Firefox with the privacy disrespecting garbage removed, consider using Waterfox, which is a more privacy-centric, 64 bit fork of Firefox that will apparently continue to support XUL (legacy) extensions in addition to the newer WebExtensions. Some of the features of Waterfox are:
- Disabled Encrypted Media Extensions (EME)
- Removed Pocket
- Removed Telemetry
- Removed data collection
- Removed startup profiling
- Allow running of all 64-Bit NPAPI plugins
- Allow running of unsigned extensions
- Removal of Sponsored Tiles on New Tab Page
UPDATE: Mozilla apologizes.
On 18-Dec., after many users complained about the inclusion of the Looking Glass add-on, for which almost nothing was known at the time it was distributed, Mozilla published an apology, moved the add-on to the Mozilla add-on repository and published the source code. The post opened with the following nonsensical statement which raises more questions than it answers:
Over the course of the year Firefox has enjoyed a growing relationship with the Mr. Robot television show and, as part of this relationship, we developed an unpaid collaboration to engage our users and viewers of the show in a new way: Fans could use Firefox to solve a puzzle as part of the alternate reality game (ARG) associated with the show.
Does this sound remotely like anything that should be included in an internet web browser? What is the nature of Mozilla’s relationship with Mr. Robot? We already know that Mozilla has a habit of adding unnecessary functionality through its inclusion of 3rd party services for monetary gain and using its relationships with many privacy destroying corporations, such as Google, to monetize necessary functionality, yet they packaged the Looking Glass add-on with Firefox for no other reason other than, what? They like Mr. Robot? They wanted to make sure you weren’t bored by giving you a game to play? Utter bullshit. And why wasn’t the source code published before the add-on was shipped? And how do we know that the published code is identical to the unpublished code?
The rollout did not meet the standards to which we hold ourselves causing concern that was surfaced through our Firefox community.
Yes it did because Mozilla sacrificed its standards long ago. The only reason they published this apology is because enough users complained.
We received feedback regarding the transparency of the rollout and the processes that govern our auto-install mechanism for add-ons. In response we immediately started our internal review, […]
Good thing most users have no clue about the several system add-ons and “features” that ship with Firefox which are forcefully installed, activated, not easily uninstalled, and are used to collect data. Of course we know that no internal review will be performed to address this glaring privacy issue.
We’re sorry for the confusion and for letting down members of our community. While there was no intention or mechanism to collect or share your data or private information […]
When one considers exactly what Mozilla defines as “user data” and “private information”, one realizes how hollow this misleading claim rings. If they’re so concerned about their users, why aren’t they concerned about the data that is still being collected by the forcefully installed system add-ons of which users are largely unaware? Why aren’t these add-ons removed and placed in the add-on repository?
- Firefox is on a slippery slope | Drew DeVault’s Blog
- The Mozilla Information Trust Initiative: Building a movement to fight misinformation online – The Mozilla Blog
- Firefox/Shield/Shield Studies – MozillaWiki
- Firefox Looking Glass extension: what it is? – gHacks Tech News
- What is Looking Glass. : firefox
- Update: Looking Glass Add-on | The Firefox Frontier
- Mozilla Foundation – Wikipedia
- GitHub – mozilla/addon-wr: Looking Glass is a collaboration between Mozilla and the makers of Mr. Robot to provide a shared world experience.
- Waterfox – The free, open and private browser
- Firefox Configuration Guide for Privacy Freaks and Performance Buffs | 12Bytes.org
A bit more content was added to the Firefox User Interface Customization article.
A bit more content was added to the Firefox User Interface Customization page, including a possible fix for those who are annoyed with the Firefox window not starting in a maximized state when it was maximized when closed (hint: the problem has to do with the
Privacy-centric search engines
Following is a table of some search engines which are more privacy-centric than those offered by the privacy-hating mega-corporations like Google, Bing and Yahoo. Note that several of the alternatives listed here are meta search engines which rely either partially or entirely upon services like Google for their search results. While these so-called “alternative search engines” are not true alternatives, they do act as a proxy between you and services like Google and thus insulate you from the privacy risks associated with them.
If you have any search engines you would like to suggest, please leave a comment (you need not be logged in).
- Decentralized – whether the service is controlled by a single entity, such as Google, or distributed among its users, as is the case with YaCy for example
- Type – meta: uses 3rd party search indexes, such as Google, to deliver search results
index: crawls the web and indexes content without relying on 3rd party search engines
hybrid: a combination of both meta and index
- Client Required – whether you have to download and install client software in order to use the service
|FAROO (search page, no SSL)||no||index||yes / no||optional||?||FAROO offers a distributed, censorship resistant, peer-to-peer search engine and index, however it is powered by proprietary client software. In answering the question “Why you don’t publish your product as Open Source?“, their response is “[…] it’s not a good idea to hand over your technological advantage to a monopoly, when competing with its free service with enormous brand power.“. A very poor answer in my personal opinion.|
|Searx (search page, SSL)||partially||meta||yes(?) if searching from the FF search bar, no if searching from the web page / no, but settings are not saved||no||n/a||Searx is a meta search engine which i have found to be the best of its type because of its capability to pull results from a wide array of third party services and it is highly configurable. The interface is clean, customizable and intuitive. Anyone can run a Searx instance on their own server (see their GitHub page).|
|YaCy (search page, SSL, self-signed certificate)||yes||index||yes / no||optional||n/a||YaCy is, in my opinion, the most interesting search engine listed here in that it is a decentralized, distributed, censorship resistant search engine and index powered by free, open-source software. At this time YaCy doesn’t produce a lot of pertinent search results, however the more people use it, the better it will become. For those wanting to run your own instance of YaCy, see their home page and their GitHub page. This article from Digital Ocean may also be of help if you want to run YaCy on a VPS.|
Upcoming search engines
- Presearch: a decentralized search engine powered by the community
- Seeks: a websearch proxy and collaborative distributed tool for websearch
Please leave a comment if you know of any others.
- 5 Best Search Engines That Respect Your Privacy – BestVPN.com
- 12 Private Search Engines that Do Not Track You – Hongkiat
- Alternative Search Engines | Oregon Computer Solutions
- Distributed Search Engines – P2P Foundation
- P2P Search as an Alternative to Google: Recapturing network value through decentralized search » The Journal of Peer Production